Notice
Lost money online? Call 1930 or report at cybercrime.gov.in immediately Cheque returned unpaid? The demand notice must go within 30 days of the return memo Never share an OTP, UPI PIN or screen-sharing access with anyone Received a police notice? Keep a copy and take legal advice before you respond Chamber: 3RD FLOOR KRISHNA MANSION CIVIL LINES GURUGRAM
Open 24 hours +91 9560498295

Cheque Bounce

Cheque Bounced: Criminal Case under Section 138, Civil Recovery Suit, or Both?

A bounced cheque can lead to a criminal complaint under Section 138, a civil recovery suit, or both at the same time. Here is how the two differ and when each one makes sense.

"Sir, I just want my money back. Should I file the cheque bounce case or a recovery suit?" I hear some version of this question often. The person has a bounced cheque, a cheque return memo from the bank, and a fair amount of frustration. What they usually do not know is that the law gives them two separate roads, and in many cases they can take both.

Let me explain how each road works, what it can and cannot do, and how people usually decide.

Two different remedies for the same cheque

The first is the criminal complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. It punishes the act of issuing a cheque that bounces for a legally enforceable debt, after a proper demand notice is ignored. It is filed before the court of the Judicial Magistrate, and the person who issued the cheque comes as an accused.

The second is a civil suit for recovery of money. Here the court is not asked to punish anyone. It is asked to pass a decree that the defendant owes a certain amount, with interest, which can then be executed against his bank accounts or property. For cheques, this is very often filed as a summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Courts have consistently treated these as independent remedies. One is about a criminal offence, the other about a civil debt. Filing one does not stop you from filing the other, and the outcome of one does not automatically decide the other.

What the Section 138 case gives you

A Section 138 case has a strict timetable. The cheque must be presented within its validity, the demand notice must go within 30 days of receiving the return memo, the drawer gets 15 days to pay, and the complaint must be filed within one month after those 15 days end. Miss these and the criminal route becomes difficult.

If the accused is convicted, the law allows imprisonment up to two years, or a fine up to twice the cheque amount, or both. The court can order the fine, or a part of it, to be paid to the complainant as compensation. During the trial, the court may also order interim compensation of up to 20% under Section 143A.

Why do people prefer it? Practical pressure. An accused who has to attend every date in the court of the JMIC, furnish bail and face the possibility of a sentence often becomes much more serious about settlement. A large number of these cases end in a compromise, which the law permits at any stage.

The limits are just as real. The case only covers the cheque amount and what the court awards. It does not, by itself, attach property. And if the accused proves there was no legally enforceable debt on the date of presentation, the complaint fails.

What a civil recovery suit gives you

A civil suit can claim the whole amount due, not just the cheque amount, along with interest and costs. If someone owes you more than what the cheque covered, or there were several transactions, the civil suit is where the full account gets settled.

The decree is enforceable through execution. That means attachment of bank accounts, salary or property, if the defendant still does not pay. A criminal court cannot do this in the same way.

The civil road also has its own time limit. A suit has to be filed within the limitation period under the Limitation Act, which is generally three years, but the date from which it runs depends on the facts: the nature of the loan, the cheque date, any written acknowledgement of the debt. Do not wait till the last few months to find out.

Why the summary suit under Order XXXVII matters

An ordinary civil suit can take years. Order XXXVII was designed to speed things up for claims based on written documents, and a cheque is one such document.

In simple terms, it works like this:

  • The defendant is served and has 10 days to enter appearance.
  • The plaintiff then serves a "summons for judgment".
  • The defendant must apply for leave to defend within 10 days of that summons.
  • If leave is not sought, or the court finds the defence is not real, the court can pass a decree without a full trial.

Leave to defend is not automatic. The defendant has to show a genuine, triable defence. A vague story is not enough. Where the court sees some substance but doubts it, it can grant leave on condition that the defendant deposits money in court. This is why summary suits often move faster than people expect.

One more point. If the transaction is commercial, for example between traders or businesses, and the claim is ₹3 lakh or more, the suit generally goes before the commercial court. In that case pre-institution mediation is usually required first, unless urgent interim relief is being sought.

Criminal case or civil suit: a quick comparison

Section 138 complaintCivil / summary suit
PurposePunish the bounced cheque offenceRecover the debt
Time limitVery strict (30 days, 15 days, one month)Limitation period, generally three years depending on facts
AmountLinked to the cheque; fine up to twice the amountWhole amount due, with interest and costs
Recovery toolFine and compensation; pressure to settleDecree, executable against accounts and property
Court feeNominalAd valorem, based on the amount claimed

Can you file both at the same time?

Yes. This is common, and there is nothing wrong with it. The criminal case keeps pressure on the drawer. The civil suit protects the full claim and gives you a decree that can actually be executed.

You will not get the same money twice. The law provides that when compensation has already been paid in a criminal case, a civil court dealing with the same matter takes it into account. And if the matter settles in one forum, the settlement terms should clearly say what happens to the other case.

What I usually tell people is this: if the amount is small and the other side is likely to pay once summoned, the Section 138 route alone is often enough. If the amount is large, if the cheque covers only part of the dues, or if you suspect the other side may sell property or move money, a civil suit alongside it makes sense. Court fee is a factor too, since a civil suit costs more to file.

What if you missed the Section 138 deadlines?

This is where the civil suit becomes important. If the notice went late or the complaint could not be filed in time, the criminal road may be closed, but your money claim is not gone. Read what can still be done after missing a cheque bounce deadline. A recovery suit within limitation is usually the main option left.

What to do

  1. Keep the original cheque, the bank's return memo and any loan or invoice documents safely. Do not hand over originals to anyone without a receipt.
  2. Note the date you received the return memo and calculate the 30-day notice deadline straight away.
  3. Send the Section 138 demand notice in time, even if you are also thinking about a civil suit. The notice keeps the criminal option open.
  4. Put together the full account of what is owed, not just the cheque amount.
  5. Decide, with advice on your facts, whether to file the complaint, the suit, or both.
  6. If a settlement offer comes, get it in writing and make sure it deals with every pending case.

A closing thought

A bounced cheque feels like one problem, but it really raises two questions: has an offence been committed, and how do I get my money? The Section 138 case answers the first and often helps with the second. The civil suit answers the second directly. Choosing well at the start, while all the time limits are still open, saves a lot of trouble later. For more on how these cases run in practice, see the page on the work of a cheque bounce lawyer in Gurugram.

This article is general information, not legal advice. The right course depends on the facts and documents of each case.

Adv. Dinesh Sharma

Written by

Adv. Dinesh Sharma

Advocate practising criminal law at Gurugram, in cyber crime and cheque bounce matters.

Practice areas: cyber crime lawyer in Gurugram · cheque bounce lawyer in Gurugram

About the advocate →

This article is general information, not legal advice. The law and its interpretation change; speak to an advocate about your own facts.

Continue reading

More on cheque bounce

WhatsApp